| Challenge the Philosophy - Competition 2 & Entry Form |
| The challenge is to overcome
the proposition, we are [more reasonably] human beings who are part of
the causal infinity of existence. To find out, within limit, whether
the proposition can be overcome or not, and to reward an individual or group
for excellent work, Inexpressible Publications will publish the idea, and
explanation, of any individual or group who overcomes the proposition within
the limit of more reasonableness. (Note, this competition on more reasonably
who we are is a natural extension of the competition on whether or not we
can more reasonably truly know and be who we are at the same time. Chris
Brown from Entry 411 on truly knowing and being who we are is credited with
first suggesting this particular competition.)
The challenge will be in effect for an indefinite period of time, or until an individual or group overcomes the proposition within the time-frame. Definitions of principal terms used in the competition: "We are [more reasonably]": limited knowledge of who we are which is more sound and consistent than antagonistic limited knowledge of who we are. (Limited knowledge refers to knowledge that is not completely known.) "We": the individuals who make up humanity. "Human beings": the individual members of the human species who are generally defined by sentience, corporeal aspects (e.g. biological and neurological properties), and non-corporeal aspects (e.g. consciousness and life-force). Note, it is possible that consciousness and life-force, for example, may be corporeal aspects of human existence. "Part": human beings as interconnected members of existence. "Causal infinity": the unending interactive relationship between things. For further explanation, see causal infinity. "Existence": the interaction between things based on an inexpressible force. "Overcome": more reasonable refutation of the proposition, "we are [more reasonably] human beings who are part of the causal infinity of existence." "More reasonable refutation" entails using reason in the most objective manner possible, and includes the arguments stated in the entries and disputes submitted to this "Challenge the Philosophy" competition, and the arguments stated in the responses to them. Also, one idea or position is deemed more reasonable than another idea or position if it is more sound and consistent. (Overcoming the proposition can entail more reasonably refuting its terms and the concepts behind them, if the meaning of the proposition itself is significantly altered through the incorporation of new terms and concepts.) Defense of the proposition: For a summary of the main arguments supporting the proposition, see arguments. Implication of the proposition: By human beings being part of the causal infinity of existence, we establish an interconnected relationship between ourselves and all other things, so that everything else is indirectly part of who we are. Hence, to change things whether we are highly dependent on them or not, is change who we are. In other words, everything around us is an extension, at some level, of who we are; so by changing other things, we are changing ourselves.
If you think the challenge proposition cannot be overcome, in concise words tell us why using the entry form below. (Explanations submitted will likely be posted.) |
|
~ Entry Form ~ |
|
Conditions for the Competition Entries: The Entry Form below must be filled out and sent via e-mail to Inexpressible Publications. Photocopies of the entry form will be accepted. However, no e-mail attachments or faxes containing entries will be accepted. Lengthy entries or any other lengthy submissions can be mailed to: Inexpressible Publications P.O. Box 42 Kimberley, B.C. V1A 2Y5 Attention: The "Challenge the Philosophy" competition, or e-mailed as non-attachments to Inexpressible Publications using the Entry Form below. The competition is open to anyone. There is no limit, barring repetition, on the number of entries or other submissions submitted by a single participant. Entries and other submissions must be concise. However, there is no word limit on submissions. Group Entries: A group can entail any organization of people including clubs, classes, departments, and societies. There is no group size limit. Also, there is no limit on the number of entries a group can submit. The name of the group and all other relevant information must be filled out in the entry form. The names of groups will be posted on the inexpressible site following their entries. Evaluation of Entries: The evaluation of the entries will be based solely on reason. Inexpressible Publications in consultation with the Committee will be the final authority on whether or not a participant's entry overcomes the Challenge proposition. Entries will be evaluated in the order they are received. Depending on the number of entries received, it may take two weeks to respond to an entry. The committee members are chosen for their objectivity, open-mindedness, and analytical skills based on what they have said and written in the past. The members are kept anonymous. Replies and Disputes: Replies to entries or disputes regarding decisions are to be mailed to IP c/o The Inexpressible Committee, or sent using this e-mail Replies & Disputes, or any of the e-mails for Inexpressible Publications on the inexpressible website. (Comments can be mailed to IP c/o The Inexpressible Committee, or sent using this e-mail Letters.) Similar to entries, replies and disputes are evaluated in the order they are received. (Entries, replies, and disputes are given equal priority.) Requests to reread entries or other submissions will be accepted as long as there is sufficient grounds for doing so. Any unresolvable disputes will be referred to third party arbitration. If a dispute is still not resolvable, a two week public assessment will commence, in which all participants will be notified and asked to participate. At the end of the two weeks, the Inexpressible Committee will make a decision on the dispute. Appeals of the Inexpressible Committee's decisions will be accepted as long as new arguments are presented. Quotes: Quotes will be taken from the entries and other submissions, and posted in a quote section. Winning Entry: The winner of the competition, if there is one, will be based on his or her entry submitted. All participants in the competition will have opportunity to assess a potential winning entry in a two week public forum, and at the end of competition (indefinite time period) for another two week period. If the entry has passed the initial two week public scrutiny, further evaluation by the Inexpressible Committee, and there is still time left in the competition, the new proposition will be adopted for the remainder of the competition or until another proposition more reasonably refutes it. The winning entry at the end of the competition (indefinite time period), if there is one, will be declared to all participants and posted online. The winner's idea, and explanation, will be published by IP within one year of winning the competition. The originator of the winning idea, and not anyone representing he or her, will be published. The winning competitor will be notified in writing. In the case of a group winning, only the group, and not anyone else representing them, will be published. Publication: The winning idea, and explanation of it, will be published in a paperback book. The book will not exceed 35,000 words, including an introduction by IP. The format, structure, editing, covers, and the price of the book, and anything else pertaining to the book, will be decided, in final, by IP. Though the author's input on things pertaining to the book will be carefully considered by IP in any decisions it makes on the book. 100 to 1000 copies of the book will be printed to begin, and with more to follow based on demand. The winning author will receive 10% royalty on sales of the book. IP has the rights for selling the book, including transfering its rights to another party. As part of the publication of the book, the author will be expected to help with the promotion of the book. Promotion by the author entails giving talks and readings, and responding to questions from readers. In the case of a group winning, the publication will authored only by the group. The 10% royalty on sales will be sent to the group. Also, the group will be expected to help with the promotion of the book. Miscellaneous: Participants have copyright over the written material, whether entries and replies, or any other submissions, they supply to inexpressible.com. Though IP may freely reproduce in html, print, electronic, or in any other forms, the written material supplied by participants. However, if a participant requests in writing that his or her material not be reproduced, IP will respect his or her request. Personal information of participants submitted through the competition is strictly confidential. It will not be used in anyway outside of the bounds of the competition, or released to anyone except in an extreme situation in which Inexpressible Publications is legally forced to release the information. IP reserves the right to determine whether or not an entry or other submissions will be posted. Participants will be notified if their entries, or any other submissions, are posted on the inexpressible site. Also, if it takes longer than three weeks to respond to an entry, or other submission, the Inexpressible Committee will notify the participant, telling the participant the expected time the submission will be responded to. The Inexpressible Committee reserves the right to edit entries or other submissions for spelling, grammar, and wordiness. Entries and other submissions will be rejected if they do not show an attempt by the participants to conform to the basic requirements of the English written language like correct punctuation and capitalization. However, if a participant goes outside the norms of the English language to help express an idea related to the competition, his or her entry will be accepted. Though the terms of the proposition are a set part of the competition, they can be refuted to overcome the proposition. (Refutation is subject to what is more reasonable.) The conditions of the competition may be subject to change for the sole purpose of improving the administration of the competition, thereby to better determine if the challenge proposition can be overcome or not. The explanations of the proposition's terms may be subject to change, including further elaboration, solely to clarify the meanings of the terms. Further details on the publication of the winning entry will be presented to the winning author once he or she is determined. As mentioned, the competition is open to anyone, including relations and relatives of the members of Inexpressible Publications and the Inexpressible Committee to ensure that the most perspectives are heard. IP is not responsible for entry forms lost in the mail. |
Participant's Information